Summary
Israel faces a potentially consequential shift in American politics as opposition to the U.S.-Israel alliance grows within both major parties. Changes in congressional leadership, uncertainty over future military assistance, and increasingly hostile public attitudes could undermine decades of strategic cooperation. Israel must respond through sustained bipartisan engagement, stronger public diplomacy, coordinated efforts to counter delegitimization, and expanded regional security partnerships. Protecting the alliance requires immediate action to cultivate new supporters while maintaining relationships with longstanding allies.
Key Takeaways
- Israel Can No Longer Take Bipartisan American Support for Granted. The Democratic Party's growing anti-Israel faction, shifting Republican attitudes, and the possibility of a future administration less supportive of Israel threaten the longstanding U.S.-Israel alliance. Israel must strengthen relationships with lawmakers and political leaders across both parties, including those who are skeptical but open to engagement.
- Changes to U.S. Military Assistance Could Create New Security Challenges. Even if Israel transitions away from American military grants, Congress will retain substantial influence over arms sales and defense cooperation. Sustained diplomatic engagement, particularly with members of key congressional committees, will remain essential to protecting Israel's security interests.
- Countering Anti-Israel Narratives Requires a Coordinated, Long-Term Strategy. Israel and its supporters must expand educational outreach, challenge misinformation, engage undecided Americans, and strengthen cooperation among Jewish and non-Jewish organizations. Credible communication, bipartisan diplomacy, and regional security partnerships will be crucial to preserving American support.
Israel is fortunate to have friends such as President Trump, whose record on Israel is unmatched, in my view. His term ends on January 20, 2029, and I expect him to maintain the strong commitment to Israel he demonstrated during his first term and has continued to demonstrate during his second. But the political landscape in Washington is changing. Israel must prepare for a more challenging Congress during the final two years of his presidency and for the possibility of a very different approach from whoever occupies the White House afterward. A growing number of members of Congress are strongly opposed to Israel, and some potential presidential candidates in both the Republican and Democratic parties may take similar positions. Yet many others, including some who are skeptical of the American-Israeli relationship today, may be willing to support it or cooperate on matters of mutual interest.
The blue tsunami that swept across the United States on Election Day raises serious concerns for me about U.S. domestic policy as well as foreign affairs, especially the country’s relationship with Israel. The consequences for that relationship could be profound, both in the new Congress taking office in January and potentially in the presidential administration that follows President Trump.
The new Democratic majority will control congressional committees, influence defense spending, and exercise considerable oversight of foreign policy. Some members are deeply hostile to Israel. Others have long supported the alliance, while some may be open to closer relationships through sustained engagement by Israeli officials and advocates who listen to their concerns, explain Israel’s positions clearly and thoroughly, and identify opportunities for cooperation. Writing off the Democratic Party would mean abandoning important allies when their support is needed most.
Representatives Tom Suozzi, Laura Gillen, and Jared Moskowitz, all reelected, have publicly supported Israel and the American-Israeli relationship. All three cosponsored the United States-Israel Defense Partnership Act, which would expand cooperation on counter-drone systems and advanced defense technologies. Suozzi and Moskowitz also cosponsored the bipartisan U.S.-Israel Anti-Killer Drone Act. Neither bill has yet become law. Israel should work with these representatives and others like them and also reach out to Democrats whose positions are less firmly established.
The growing influence of the Democratic Party’s anti-Israel left demands immediate and serious attention. Abdul El-Sayed, elected to the Senate from Michigan, has called Israel a “rogue state,” accused it of genocide and apartheid, and told CNN that he considers the Israeli government just as evil as Hamas.
In an August CNN interview, El-Sayed said: “I don’t believe that there’s really a difference between offensive or defensive weapons.” He added that he did not consider it his responsibility to buy defensive weapons for a foreign government when Michigan schools were underfunded. Asked whether he opposed American funding for Israel’s Iron Dome missile-defense system, he replied, “I am against it.”
In June 2025, the Iranian regime launched about 550 ballistic missiles at Israel. During the first 40 days of this year’s war against the Iranian regime, Iran launched more than 500 additional missiles. Israeli civilians were killed, thousands were injured, and buildings were destroyed or badly damaged.
Israel’s layered missile defenses, including Iron Dome and the jointly developed Arrow and David’s Sling systems, have saved countless lives. Without these defenses, the missiles and rockets fired at Israel would have caused far more death and destruction. El-Sayed opposes American funding even for defensive systems intended to protect civilians. This cooperation also serves American interests. The United States and Israel jointly develop and test missile-defense systems, and American companies manufacture important components for Iron Dome, Arrow, and David’s Sling, supporting American defense manufacturing and jobs.
On the other side of the political aisle, Israel can no longer take Republican support for granted. There is no assurance that the party’s future leaders or voters will share President Trump’s views about Israel.
On November 4, Vice President JD Vance cited a pollster who asked people who voted for President Trump in 2024 and were planning to vote Democratic in 2026 what would bring them back to the Republicans. The leading answers, he said, included ending the war, addressing inflation, putting America first, and changing America’s relationship with Israel. Vance argued that defections to the Democrats, rather than low Republican turnout, were the main problem.
William Galston of the Brookings Institution disputed that explanation. He pointed to exit polling suggesting that 7% of voters in 2026 who had backed Trump and Vance in 2024 voted for Democrats, arguing that Republicans staying home in large numbers better explained the defeat. Galston also acknowledged that many Republicans and Democrats favor revising America’s relationship with Israel, even if he believes economic concerns mattered more to voters.
If accurate, that 7% figure represents a substantial number of Americans who supported President Trump in 2024 but voted for Democrats in 2026. We do not know how many were influenced by attitudes toward Israel. But even if Israel was a factor for only some of them, we need to understand why. And if Galston is right that many Republicans stayed home, we should ask whether attitudes toward Israel or the war against the Iranian regime contributed to their decision.
We may never know precisely whether Vance or Galston has the better explanation. Israel and its supporters cannot afford to wait for certainty. We should treat Vance’s warning as potentially correct, even if we dislike what it suggests, and respond accordingly. If he is wrong, the effort can still strengthen the relationship. If he is right and we dismiss his message because it is uncomfortable, we will have lost valuable time. No credible warning should be ignored.
Even President Trump, Israel’s staunch ally, identified the war, higher gasoline prices, and what he called “a great dislike, incredibly, for Israel” as the primary reasons for Republican losses in his November 8 interview with 60 Minutes. He was describing what he believed voters were thinking, not announcing a change in his own support for Israel. Indeed, he defended his decision to confront the Iranian regime to prevent it from acquiring a nuclear weapon. His observation, like Vance’s, is an important assessment of changing American attitudes toward Israel that we would be foolish to ignore.
Israel and its supporters should engage Vance now, explain the threats Israel faces, listen to his concerns, and show how the relationship advances American security. That includes a serious discussion of the Iranian regime, the costs of conflict, and the benefits of defense cooperation.
I hear plenty of criticism of the vice president. Valid or not, criticism alone achieves little. If he runs for president and wins, we should not be left wondering why we failed to make our case when we had the chance.
While I was at the White House, I dealt with everyone: Democrats and Republicans, Israelis and Arabs, Christians, Muslims, and Jews. Diplomacy requires engaging with people we disagree with, patiently explaining what we believe and why, listening to their concerns, and finding ways forward even when full agreement is impossible. That was the basis for the Abraham Accords. It is also the basis for cooperation across the region and for the support Israel so sorely needs in Washington.
Israeli leaders must devote more attention to lawmakers in both parties, particularly those who are new, skeptical, or unfamiliar with Israel’s security challenges. Waiting until a weapons purchase is challenged or damaging legislation is proposed will be too late.
Officials should meet lawmakers in Washington, invite them to Israel, listen carefully, and give thorough, credible answers to tough questions. They should explain security decisions and, when appropriate, pursue cooperation that serves American interests. Israel must make its own decisions, especially on security. Still, it should understand how those decisions affect its closest and most important ally and the potential consequences when their approaches diverge.
The future of American military assistance makes these relationships particularly important. On November 3, President Trump said he and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had agreed to end American military grants to Israel by the end of 2026. Greater Israeli financial independence is a worthy goal, but the timing and terms remain unsettled.
Some media reports describe negotiations over a different timetable: roughly $3.3 billion in annual direct military grants for five years after the current agreement expires in 2028, rather than ten, followed by an end to those grants. Joint missile-defense funding could increase. These reports differ from the earlier announcement, and it remains unclear exactly what the governments have agreed to or what Congress will ultimately fund.
The existing agreement provides about $3.8 billion annually, including missile-defense funding, through fiscal year 2028. Whatever follows will require congressional appropriations. The transition should strengthen joint research, development, and production rather than weaken the security cooperation that benefits both countries.
Even when Israel buys American weapons with its own money, major sales remain subject to congressional review. Informal committee objections can delay them. Israel could have the funds to purchase vital equipment yet face obstacles to obtaining it. That is why relationships with lawmakers, including members of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and House Foreign Affairs Committee, which review major arms sales before formal notification, remain essential after any transition away from grants.
American supporters of Israel also have responsibilities. They should support candidates who defend the alliance, volunteer, meet their representatives, and follow legislation affecting the relationship. Last-minute calls during a crisis are no substitute for sustained engagement.
Jewish and non-Jewish organizations supporting Israel must also work together more effectively. They may disagree over American politics, religious matters, the Israeli-Palestinian peace process, and the policies of Israeli governments. Those disagreements need not be resolved, and each organization can continue advocating its views. But they should unite where they agree: defending Israel’s legitimacy, countering growing hostility, and explaining the value of the American-Israeli relationship.
They should share educational resources, coordinate briefings, and train students and adults to explain Israel’s history, the threats it faces, and the debates over its policies.
The opposition to Israel is extremely active, highly organized, and, in some cases, extremely well-funded. Campaigns on campuses, in institutions, and across social media spread allegations rapidly. Many Americans who know little about Israel encounter hostile or distorted accounts every day. Supporters of Israel have underestimated the effort needed to reach them.
Confronting the campaign to delegitimize the Jewish state must become an urgent, permanent priority for Israelis and Israel’s supporters worldwide.
The accusations of genocide and apartheid are false and must be challenged in universities, international institutions, legislatures, newsrooms, and online. Through relentless repetition, many of these claims have come to be accepted as facts. Reversing that trend requires evidence, serious research, and knowledgeable people willing to challenge the claims directly.
Some determined opponents will never be satisfied by changes in Israeli policies or American assistance. For them, this is not about Gaza, Judea and Samaria (which many call the West Bank), Lebanon, Syria, or judicial reform. Their fundamental objection is to Israel’s very existence as the Jewish state.
Such opponents will find another grievance whatever Israel does. Their efforts to delegitimize the Jewish state must be confronted directly. But they should not be confused with people who genuinely disagree with Israeli policies, even strongly, or who are still forming their views.
Those undecided people should be a particular priority. Anti-Israel activists are working hard to shape their views. Supporters of Israel should make the same effort to reach them: listen to their questions, respond with facts, and seek common ground rather than abandoning them to one-sided narratives.
Social media and artificial intelligence have made this harder. False accounts can spread rapidly, and fabricated images or videos are increasingly convincing. The Israeli government should provide verified information, original footage, and context promptly, in clear, plain English. Accuracy is essential: a misleading response that requires correction damages credibility.
Supporters of Israel should share accurate information beyond their own like-minded circles. Organizations can pool resources for verification and translation and work with younger communicators who know how to reach people online.
The Israeli government also has responsibilities. Extremist rhetoric from Israeli politicians causes real diplomatic damage that outside advocates cannot easily repair.
Israel should deepen practical cooperation with Gulf countries that share concerns about the Iranian regime and its proxies, even when they differ in their approaches to Tehran. The Abraham Accords offer a foundation for early warning, missile defense, maritime security, and protection of critical infrastructure. These projects can help protect Israeli and Gulf populations and advance American security.
Lebanon and Syria present harder challenges, but credible, enforceable security arrangements that reduce attacks and constrain armed groups should be explored. Even limited agreements that endure could improve Israeli security and reduce the risk of another conflict drawing in American forces.
A future Democratic administration need not be hostile to Israel. At the same time, continued Republican support cannot be assumed. Israel has friends in both parties and much to contribute to American security.
The coming years will be challenging. We must use them to strengthen existing relationships and build new ones capable of withstanding serious disagreements, contested weapons sales, and difficult security decisions.
I have seen determined diplomacy accomplish what many considered impossible. Success is not guaranteed. But if we allow support for Israel to erode without doing everything within our power to prevent it, we will bear responsibility for the consequences. We have the opportunity to act now. We must not waste it.