Alerts

Why Does the PA Fund Terrorists Instead of Building Hospitals?

The money paid to cover PA's terror army’s salaries could have been used to build hospitals and improve the health care provided to the Palestinians.
Palestinian security forces in Jenin.
Palestinian security forces in Jenin. (Nasser Ishtayeh/Flash90)

Table of Contents

Summary

The Palestinian Authority is accused of maintaining security forces substantially larger than the level contemplated under the Oslo arrangements. From 2008 through 2025, spending on salaries and social benefits for these forces is stated to have exceeded $20 billion, with about $16 billion attributed to personnel beyond the cited limit. This spending is contrasted with shortcomings in Palestinian health infrastructure and continued reliance on treatment in Israel. The argument concludes that Palestinian leadership prioritized security capabilities over investment in civilian needs.

Key Takeaways

  • The Palestinian Authority Security Forces are described as having grown to roughly five times the personnel level envisioned under the Oslo framework.
  • PA budget reports are cited as showing more than NIS 62 billion in security-force salaries and social benefits between 2008 and 2025, with roughly NIS 50 billion characterized as spending above what a smaller force would have required.
  • The central argument is that resources devoted to security forces could instead have supported hospitals, health care, and other civilian services.

For the past 20 years, the Palestinian Authority, in complete breach of the Oslo Accords, has built a massive terror army.1 While the Oslo Accords envisaged the PA operating a civilian police force numbering 12,000 personnel, the PA never respected this limitation. In practice, as the following graph shows, for two decades the number of members of the PA Security Forces (PASF) has ballooned to five times the agreed size:

Number of members in the PASF2

Chart: Number of members in the PASF

According to budget performance reports published by the PA, from 2008 through 2025, the PA spent over $20 billion (NIS 62,245,826,504) on salaries and social benefits for PASF members.

In other words, had the PA complied with its commitments, it could have saved approximately $16 billion (NIS 49,796,661,203) in salaries alone instead of building the terror army.

To this day, the PA does not have a modern and professional hospital,3 and still sends thousands of Palestinians every year to receive medical treatment in Israel. The additional money paid to cover the salaries of the PA’s terror army could have been used, for example, to build hospitals and improve the health care provided to the Palestinians.

Unfortunately for the Palestinians, the PA and the Palestinian leadership place greater value on building the terror force it intends to use to attack Israel, rather than providing the Palestinians with basic services, such as health care and building hospitals.

In the same way that Hamas spent hundreds of millions of dollars building the Gazan terror tunnels instead of building and developing the “Gazan Riviera,” the PA in Judea and Samaria has spent over $16 billion building a terror army, rather than providing for the basic needs of the Palestinians.

* * *

Notes

FAQ
How large are the Palestinian Authority Security Forces described as being?
They are described as approximately five times the 12,000-person level cited as having been contemplated under the Oslo arrangements.
How much was reportedly spent on security-force personnel?
PA budget performance figures are cited as totaling NIS 62.25 billion, described as more than $20 billion, in salaries and social benefits from 2008 through 2025.
What alternative use for the money is proposed?
Approximately NIS 49.8 billion, described as about $16 billion, is presented as expenditure that could instead have been directed toward hospitals, health care, and other basic civilian services.

Lt.-Col. (res.) Maurice Hirsch

Lt.-Col. (res.) Maurice Hirsch served as Director of the Military Prosecution for Judea and Samaria. Since retiring from the IDF, Hirsch worked as the Head of Legal Strategies for Palestinian Media Watch, as a Senior Military Consultant for NGO Monitor, an advisor to the Ministry of Defense, and head of an advisory committee in the Ministry of Interior. Hirsch was the architect of the Israeli law that strips citizenship from Israeli terrorists who have been convicted for terror offenses, sentenced to a custodial sentence, and receive a payment from the Palestinian Authority as a reward for their acts of terror.
Share this

Invest in JCFA

Subscribe to Daily Alert

The Daily Alert – Israel news digest appears every Sunday, Tuesday, and Thursday.

Related Items

Stay Informed, Always

Subscribe to Jerusalem Issue Briefs
Concise analytical papers focusing on Israeli security, diplomacy, and foreign policy.
The highly-acclaimed Daily Alert Israel news digest includes the most important and timely articles from around the world on Israel, the Middle East and U.S. policy.